top of page

Why People Struggle With Change: Change Readiness and Five Questions Every Leader Should Ask

Writer: Psychology360
Psychology360
10 minutes ago
7 min read

Why do employees resist organisational change? Explore five research-backed questions to assess change readiness and help your team adapt effectively.


Organisational change is a constant in today's world of work. Whether you're introducing new technology, restructuring a team, shifting operating models, or responding to market pressures, change is part of modern professional life and managing change is a key leadership skill. Yet, even when a change makes undeniable business sense, people don't always respond the way we expect them to and often we experience employee resistance.

We’ve all been there: a leadership team is energised and excited about a new strategic direction, while the people actually tasked with executing it appear hesitant, frustrated, or disengaged. When this happens, it's easy to label the reaction as "resistance to change."


We might catch ourselves questioning whether our people are adaptable enough, resilient enough, or open-minded enough. But as practitioners, there's a far more useful question we can ask:

"What does someone need to understand, believe, or experience before they're ready to engage constructively with this specific change?"


This is where the psychology of change readiness offers a much clearer lens.


What Is Change Readiness?

One of the most valuable distinctions in organisational psychology is the difference between a person’s general capacity to adapt and their readiness for a specific change. You can be an exceptionally resilient, flexible individual and still feel deeply uncertain about a particular organisational decision.


Imagine someone who has successfully navigated multiple restructures, leadership turnovers, and high-pressure business shifts throughout their career. They certainly consider themselves adaptable. Yet, when their company announces a brand-new operating model, they find themselves full of questions and scepticism:

  • They might not understand why the current structure needed fixing in the first place.

  • They might agree that improvement is necessary, but disagree entirely with the proposed solution.

  • They might worry whether they have the skills, time, or resources to succeed under the new rules.

These are entirely different concerns, and each demands a completely different response from leadership.


This distinction is supported by empirical research. Holt and colleagues (2007) found that readiness is a multidimensional construct, identifying dimensions such as perceived appropriateness, change efficacy, management support, and personal valence. Related work by Armenakis and colleagues developed a five-belief framework, adding discrepancy, or the perceived need for change.

Together, these studies give leaders a useful way to understand what may be helping or holding people back.


The Five Beliefs of Change Readiness


Adapted from the foundational work of Armenakis and Harris (2002) and Armenakis et al. (2007), these five questions govern how an individual processes and responds to change:

  1. Discrepancy: Why do we need to change? (The Problem)

  2. Appropriateness: Is this the right change? (The Solution)

  3. Efficacy: Can I succeed in this new environment? (The Capability)

  4. Principal Support: Do I believe leadership is truly committed? (The Backing)

  5. Valence: What does this change mean for me personally? (The Personal Impact)


Let’s look at what each of these means in practice and what leaders can actually do about them.


1. Discrepancy: Why do we need to change?

Before anyone can support a change, they first need to understand why the status quo isn't viable anymore. Discrepancy is the gap between where things are right now and where they need to be.

As leaders, we live with this gap for months. We spend weeks poring over performance data, market trends, customer feedback, and financial forecasts before a decision is ever announced. By the time we communicate the change, the need for it feels glaringly obvious to us.

But our teams haven't been on that journey.

If an organisation rolls out a new performance management system because leadership finds the old one administrative and poorly aligned with strategic priorities, employees who feel the current system works just fine will immediately ask: Why are we fixing something that isn't broken? 

Until that's answered honestly, pushing implementation timelines will fall flat.

  • What leaders can do: Define the problem before pitching the solution. Share the data, explain the hidden costs of maintaining the status quo, and invite your team to share their own perspective on current operational friction. People don't have to initiate a change to understand why change is necessary.


2. Appropriateness: Is this the right change?

Understanding that a problem exists doesn't automatically mean agreeing with how you plan to fix it. Appropriateness looks at whether the proposed solution actually fits the problem.

An employee might completely agree that cross-departmental collaboration is broken, but strongly question whether restructuring reporting lines will fix it. They might believe the root cause is unclear role definitions or poor leadership habits. If you double down on messaging about the importance of collaboration without addressing their scepticism about the structure, you're talking past them.

  • What leaders can do: Walk people through your decision-making process. Share the alternatives you considered, the trade-offs you weighed, and why you landed where you did. Whenever possible, involve employees in shaping how the solution is rolled out. And remember: a team member questioning your solution is often practicing valuable critical thinking. It is worth listening to.

 

3. Efficacy: Can I succeed in the new environment?

Even when people see the problem and believe in the solution, they can still experience a crisis of confidence. Efficacy is an individual's belief in their ability to carry out what the change requires—and a team’s shared confidence that they can do it together.

Consider a professional services firm integrating artificial intelligence into its workflow. An employee might fully grasp the commercial benefits, support the investment, and want the firm to succeed. Yet, in private, they're wondering: Can I actually learn this? Will my expertise still matter? What if I fail?

Their hesitation has nothing to do with a bad attitude toward technology and everything to do with self-efficacy.

  • What leaders can do: Clarify expectations, spot skill gaps early, and give people room to practise, learn, and make mistakes without feeling that every misstep will count against them. Confidence grows through small, early wins. But keep in mind: encouragement cannot compensate for an unrealistic workload, rushed training, or broken implementation plans. Confidence requires actual capability and resources.


4. Principal Support: Do I believe the organisation is committed?

People watch what leaders do far more closely than what they say—especially when living out the change requires personal effort, political capital, or difficult choices.

If an executive team declares that collaboration is a top strategic priority, but individual performance reviews continue to reward siloed departmental metrics, employees spot the contradiction instantly. They perceive a lack of genuine principal support.

  • What leaders can do: Make your backing visible. Align your incentives, allocate actual budget, clear away systemic roadblocks, and model the new behaviours yourself. Be honest about what the organisation can and cannot provide. If you expect a new way of working, the surrounding environment has to make that behaviour possible.

 

5. Valence: What does this change mean for me?

This is perhaps the most deeply human question during any transition, and also the one organisations are most tempted to gloss over. Valence refers to the anticipated personal gains and losses tied to the change.

People evaluate how a shift will impact their autonomy, career trajectory, professional identity, daily relationships, and sense of competence. A senior manager who built their entire reputation on deep technical mastery might feel threatened by a shift toward a commercial, relationship-led leadership role. They may intellectually understand and support the business strategy while mourning the loss of what made them successful in the past.

  • What leaders can do: Create safe spaces to talk about the personal implications. Acknowledge genuine losses rather than trying to put a positive spin on everything. Not every organisational change benefits every individual equally, and pretending otherwise erodes trust. The goal is to help people make sense of their reality and find clarity on the support available to them.


Putting It Into Practice: A 30-Minute Team Reflection

The real value of this framework comes from the conversations it creates. Instead of assuming everyone needs the same pep talk, use the five beliefs to locate where readiness is stuck.

If you are leading a team through a transition, try dedicating a 30-minute team session using these reflection prompts:

  • Discrepancy: Do we genuinely understand why this change is necessary? (Response: Review evidence, context, and shared pain points.)

  • Appropriateness: Do we believe this specific approach is the right answer? (Response: Discuss alternatives, trade-offs, and invite feedback.)

  • Efficacy: Are we confident we have what it takes to execute this? (Response: Map out training, resources, and stepping-stone milestones.)

  • Principal Support: Do we trust that leadership has our backs through this? (Response: Align executive decisions, remove roadblocks, and pledge visible backing.)

  • Valence: Do we understand what this means for us personally—gains and losses alike? (Response: Hold honest conversations about personal impact and support.)

This is intended as a practical conversation tool for leaders. It is not a formal psychometric assessment.


Moving Beyond Readiness to Change Agility

Readiness gets a team off the starting block, but long-term success requires ongoing adaptation. Once a team understands the "why" and feels equipped to begin, they still need room to experiment, stumble, and calibrate as reality sets in.

This is where change agility becomes important.


Change readiness tells us what is enabling or constraining our willingness to start. Change agility governs how well we learn, adjust our behaviour, and respond as new, unexpected demands emerge. In practice, you need both. A team can be wildly enthusiastic about a change on day one, yet struggle to adapt its daily habits on day thirty. Conversely, a highly capable team might dig in its heels if it believes a change has been poorly thought out.


A Final Thought for Leaders

When someone pushes back against change, our default instinct is often to urge them to be more positive, flexible, or resilient.

Sometimes, that nudge is warranted. But before you assume someone is resistant to change, check whether the questions they are asking have actually been answered.

  • Do they understand why the change is needed?

  • Do they believe the approach makes sense?

  • Do they feel able to succeed?

  • Do they trust that leadership will support them?

  • And do they understand what the change means for them personally?

The answers may tell you far more than asking people to be more resilient ever will. What looks like stubborn resistance may actually be an important question that has not yet been answered.

 

 Sincerely,


Jessica


References & Further Reading

References

Armenakis, A. A., Bernerth, J. B., Pitts, J. P., & Walker, H. J. (2007). Organizational change recipients' beliefs scale: Development of an assessment instrument. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 43(4), 481–505. https://doi.org/10.1177/0021886307303654

Armenakis, A. A., & Harris, S. G. (2002). Crafting a change message to create transformational readiness. Journal of Organizational Change Management, 15(2), 169–183. https://doi.org/10.1108/09534810210423080

Caci, L., Nyantakyi, E., Blum, K., Sonpar, A., Schultes, M.-T., Albers, B., & Clack, L. (2025). Organizational readiness for change: A systematic review of the healthcare literature. Implementation Research and Practice, 6. https://doi.org/10.1177/26334895251334536

Holt, D. T., Armenakis, A. A., Feild, H. S., & Harris, S. G. (2007). Readiness for organizational change: The systematic development of a scale. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, 43(2), 232–255. https://doi.org/10.1177/0021886306295295

Rafferty, A. E., Jimmieson, N. L., & Armenakis, A. A. (2013). Change readiness: A multilevel review. Journal of Management, 39(1), 110–135. https://doi.org/10.1177/0149206312457417

Weiner, B. J. (2009). A theory of organizational readiness for change. Implementation Science, 4(67). https://doi.org/10.1186/1748-5908-4-67


 

 
 
 

Comments


  • Facebook
  • Instagram
bottom of page